Ten Reasons to Rewrite that Scene

June 11, 2011 at 8:41 am (Advanced/Publication, Articles by other bloggers, Writing Advice)

By The Intern.

The article is here.

Top Ten Reasons You Should Rewrite That Scene

 
When you’re revising a novel, it’s easy to lose objectivitybecome so delusional you can’t tell if you’ve just created a stinking mountain of goat poop or written the next Grapes of Wrath. Each scene starts to read like a passage in a holy text—or does it just feel that way because you’ve read it so many times the words are looping through your brain like a mantra?Fear not! INTERN is here to help. Here’s INTERN’s handy guide to figuring out when it’s time to hit the delete key and write that scene again.

10. The scene is not really a scene.

Your scene is not a scene if nothing has changed by the end of it.
Your scene is not a scene if there was no internal or external conflict, no matter how subtle.
Your scene is not a scene if you were too timid to let anything dangerous happen.
Your scene is not a scene if you were too cautious to let anything unexpected happen.
Your scene is not a scene if the reader is banging her head against the wall saying “What was the point of that stupid scene?”
Basically, your scene is not a scene.

9. The scene doesn’t achieve anything new.

Does your scene introduce important new plot information? How about new emotional information? Are the characters’ relationships developing? Or is this scene just rehashing material you’ve already covered in other scenes? You might have a case of scenis redundanitus (see here for INTERN’s post on that subject). If your scene doesn’t bring anything new to the table, what’s it doing in your story?

8. The scene isn’t “worse” enough.

Read more here.

And here’s my older cat’s response to the prodigal’s return:

2 Comments

  1. W's avatar

    W said,

    I like how you left #1 off. It made me click through, which I don’t normally do.

    • Louise Curtis's avatar

      Louise Curtis said,

      W: Mwa hahahahaha!

Leave a reply to W Cancel reply